Hard fouls increase heat
With the current playoff series between the Chicago Bulls and the Miami Heat, a new rivalry is on the rise. Although the rivalry is mainly due to Heat guard-forward James Posey’s thug actions, there have been other players involved, and plenty of hard fouls that have been cleaner than those performed by Posey.
Posey has been involved in several incidents with the Bulls prior to this season. In last year’s first round playoff series, late in the game with the Bulls comfortably ahead, Bulls guard Kirk Hinrich was running a fastbreak as Posey came and shoulder tackled him. If you see the play on video (type “Posey Hinrich,” no quotes, into YouTube), it is clear that Posey had no intentions of knocking the ball away and he was going strictly for Hinrich’s body.
On Opening Night of the 2006-07 season, Posey smashed Bulls forward Tyrus Thomas’ nose and broke it, causing Thomas to miss a few games and wear a protective mask upon return. On Dec. 27, 2006, in his third incident with the Bulls, Posey clothes-lined Bulls guard-forward Luol Deng with intention to injure as he was going up for a layup. Deng fell hard on his right wrist, which he had had surgery on just a year before. Fortunately, Posey’s attempt to injure Deng failed as his wrist was fine. For videos of this and the Thomas incident, type “Posey Deng,” no quotes, into YouTube.
Earlier in this game, Heat coach Pat Riley accused Hinrich of yanking Heat guard Dwyane Wade’s wrist, labeling him a dirty player. Riley said, “Hinrich pulled his hand. Hinrich grabbed his hand, which he does all of the time…That’s what he does anytime Dwyane comes off screens. They always either grab his shirt or hand. It’s a little bit of a tactic down below the body. The officials can’t see it. So he had Dwyane’s hand and tried to pull it out of there.”
The physical play between the two clubs continued into game two of this year’s series. In this game, Bulls forward-center P.J. Brown bumped Posey and was given a flagrant foul for it. The league rescinded it after viewing the film, and referee Steve Javie said he called the flagrant foul because Posey was bumped in the air. Late in the game, Posey fouled Thomas away from the ball on a play that looked very similar to opening night when Posey smashed Thomas’ nose. No foul was retroactively given on this play.
With this physical play between the two clubs, it brings up the question of what role hard fouls have in the NBA. In the 1990s, the NBA instituted the flagrant foul in an attempt to deter contact that put a player’s health at risk. According to the NBA rulebook, this is defined as “unnecessary and/or excessive contact.” Rule 12B, Section IV, Part A of the rulebook states that a flagrant 1 foul is a foul in which there is excessive contact but not intentional. Part B states that a flagrant 2 foul is defined as one in which the contact is deemed intentional and excessive: Posey, case in point. In the incidents with Hinrich and Deng, it is obvious his intentions were to injure.
My view is that the league should do away with Part A, as there have been clean, hard fouls for many years before this. A vicious hit that is not being done with intention to injure should not be a flagrant foul. Football and baseball allow it, without penalty, and there isn’t a huge rash of injuries because of hard hits in these sports. The players police themselves: you injure one of their guys, they’re going to take out one of your guys. However, I believe Part B should stay.
In my 10 years of watching the NBA, I have never seen actions as blatant as those performed by Posey. He had no intentions of making a play in either incident and could have caused serious injury. Say Posey actually manages to break Deng’s wrist. Deng is possibly done for the season while Posey gets off with a few games suspension. How do the Bulls get even? Knowing how the league runs and their dislike for the Bulls, using a scrub to take out Wade is the only solution I see.
While this rivalry has not escalated into fights like the one between the Heat and the Knicks in the late ’90s did, the league needs to reconsider its rules on hard fouls before this budding rivalry gets out of hand.